The Australian media tycoon Kerry Packer was suggested as a mediator in the fight by Margaret Thatcher’s government to prevent the publication of Spycatcher, the memoirs of former MI5 officer Peter Wright, according to newly released official papers.
The offer was made by Wright’s Australian counsel – and future Australian prime minister – Malcolm Turnbull as part of a proposed out-of-court settlement, files released by the National Archives show.
The young lawyer was propelled to international prominence with his aggressive cross-examination of Britain’s most senior civil servant, Sir Robert Armstrong, in the government’s ultimately doomed attempt to obtain an injunction banning publication of the Wright memoirs.
During the course of the five-week trial in Sydney in the autumn of 1986, Armstrong, the cabinet secretary, famously admitted one of his statements had been “economical with the truth” – a comment eagerly seized on as proof of British duplicity.
In a telegram to London towards the end of his witness box ordeal, the mandarin disclosed that Turnbull had approached the government’s counsel Theo Simos with an offer of talks with a view to reaching a settlement.
He said Turnbull’s proposal would involve Thatcher recognising the problem of “old spooks wanting to tell their stories” and agreeing to set up a committee of inquiry.
The aim would be to move to a system similar to that in the US, where ex-CIA officers could publish provided they had permission from their former employer.
after newsletter promotion
Turnbull said that if she agreed, Thatcher would be seen as “a champion of freedom of information and freedom of speech”, while he would do his best to say that Armstrong had done “a splendid job”.
“Very good of him, I must say,” the Whitehall mandarin drily noted.
He said Turnbull, who was a legal adviser to Packer’s media empire, had added that the tycoon – best known in Britain for his rebel World Series Cricket – “could mediate if that were necessary”.
There was little enthusiasm for the proposal on the British side. Armstrong noted the closing words of the judge that day, quoting the Roman poet Virgil: “Timeo Danaos et dona ferentes” – beware of Greeks bearing gifts.
“We certainly need to view Turnbull’s proposition in that light,” Armstrong said. “There is not much enthusiasm here for starting down this course. We do not trust our Greek.”
In London, Thatcher and her senior ministers quickly decided that a settlement on such terms was “out of the question”.
“The government could not compromise on its point of principle that a member of the Security Service could not write an unauthorised book,” they agreed.
